Best Internet Security Suites 2011 Buyers Guide

By Charles P. Jefferies

Over the last several months we reviewed 10 of the latest high-end consumer Internet security suites — today we break down the numbers and pick a winner.

Internet Security Software Solutions

The following Internet Security products are participating in this guide; all are paid-for solutions.

• McAfee Total Protection 2010
• Webroot Security Complete 2011
• BitDefender Total Security 2011
• Panda Global Protection 2011
• ESET Smart Security 4
• Trend Micro Titanium Maximum Security 2011
• Norton 360
• Kaspersky Internet Security 2011
• CA Internet Security 2011
• PC Tools Internet Security 2011

Keep in mind these suites offer more than basic anti-virus protection — they also include more advanced security features such as a firewall, anti-spam protection, parental controls, and utilities such as online backup.

Check out our Best Antivirus 2010 Buyers Guide for basic antivirus solutions; also check out our 2010 Free Antivirus Buyers Guide.

How We Test

The Internet security solutions will be objectively and subjectively rated over five categories:

• Pro-activeness and Protection (30 points)
• Ease of Use and Install (7 points)
• Parental Controls (13 points)
• Anti-Spam Filter (4 points)
• Performance Impact and Scan Time (10 points)

Pro-activeness and Protection

Since people buy these suites primarily for security purposes, this section is the most heavily weighted, accounting for 30 points out of 64 points total. It focuses on the following items:

1.     Does the software’s firewall/antispyware effectively block all simulated attacks (15 points)?

2.     How proactive is the software at detecting the virus files (15 points)?

Solution	Blocking Attacks	Pro-activeness	TOTAL
McAfee Total Protection 2010	15	10	25
Webroot Security Complete 2011	15	15	30
BitDefender Total Security 2011	15	13	28
Panda Global Protection 2011	15	13	28
ESET Smart Security 4	15	15	30
Trend Micro Maximum Security 2011	15	7	22
Norton 360	15	13	28
Kaspersky Internet Security 2011	15	15	30
CA Internet Security 2011	15	13	28
PC Tools Internet Security 2011	15	7	22

All of the suites successfully fended off our attempted firewall intrusions and spyware installs; however, the scores varied in the pro-activeness category. The top scorers were Webroot, ESET, and Kaspersky, who did the best job of handling the test virus files; they went so far as to block me from downloading the files and redirecting me off the download page. Trend Micro and PC Tools are in last place; they did not detect any of the viruses while I was downloading and only discovered them after a full system scan. All of the other suites identified the virus files during download but did not receive full points because they did not fully remove them. (Note: Our trial version of PC Tools did not include their Download Guard feature, which may have allowed the software to perform better in these tests. Bear in mind that your own trial of PC Tools may prove equally inaccurate.)